Myth-busting

Dispelling the Myths about Forced Retirement

Myth 1: “Older academics block job opportunities.”

Reality: More senior academics means more research teams and more job opportunities.

Senior academics often win grants, lead laboratories, build research groups, supervise PhD students and employ postdocs. In science, medicine, engineering and other research-intensive fields, those groups can take decades to build and are destroyed when the leadership is removed by forced retirement.

When a senior academic is forced out, the effect may not be one simple vacancy. It may be the loss of grants, teams, institutional knowledge and opportunities for younger researchers, which, in turn, reduces the number of positions available for younger academics.

Both Oxford and Cambridge claim EJRA significantly increases vacancies for younger people, but statistical analysis shows this increase is at best marginal, around 2 – 4%. EJRA is therefore unlawful because it discriminates on the basis of a “protected characteristic” (age), without justification.

Myth 2: “Forced retirement creates jobs for younger academics.”

Reality: EJRA does not create new posts. It only changes when some existing positions become vacant.

The number of job openings created by forced retirement policies is negligible. 60% of vacancies arise from academic staff leaving well before their retirement age.

Many academic vacancies arise naturally, without the need for an EJRA. People retire voluntarily, move institutions, change careers, become ill or leave for personal reasons. The campaign’s central argument is that once these factors are taken into account, the additional effect of forced retirement is too small to justify compulsory dismissal by age.

Linton et al.’s analysis of Cambridge’s data argues that Cambridge has not shown EJRA significantly improved job creation and that universities without such policies can still sustain job creation. If the average career of an academic is approximately 30 years, and EJRA shortens this by 10%, then an extra vacancy for this post appears once every 300 years.

Myth 3: “This campaign is not in the interest of younger academics”

Reality: Forced retirement is harmful to the careers of younger academics.

Early-career researchers face insecurity, short contracts, limited permanent posts and intense competition. Those problems should be taken seriously.

But forced retirement is not a serious solution. A fair system should invest in new roles, improve career pathways, support fellowships, expand research teams and create more secure academic employment.

The campaign rejects the idea that opportunity for one generation depends on forcing another out.

The UKRI provides data on grant awards by age of the PI. In their last report, 17% of the sum total of awards went to PIs aged 60 or older. These are also the largest awards, illustrating how academics over 60 years old bring in significant funding for younger academics to work on exciting research programmes. In this sense, EJRA is disadvantageous to younger academics.

Even younger academics will eventually be affected by EJRA. For example, compared to earlier generations, it is likely that these academics received a permanent post around age 40 rather than around 30. This means the EJRA may shorten their academic careers even more in the current environment. As these academics approach retirement, it becomes more challenging to take on PhD students three or four years prior to retirement, and applying for research grants becomes significantly more difficult.

With lower salaries, and higher and longer mortgage costs, retirement even at 69 is likely to have a major impact on younger academics’ standard of living. In addition, the USS has drastically cut academics’ retirement benefits. Unlike the cohorts who retired well before 2012, the pension pots of younger academics is much lower than before.

While early or mid-career academics often, understandably, don’t pay much attention to how the EJRA will affect them until they approach the age of forced retirement, they are already being impacted by its effects.

Myth 4: “Without EJRA, academics will never retire.”

Reality: People retire for many reasons, and most do so voluntarily.

Abolishing forced retirement does not mean people work forever. It means retirement is handled through choice, planning, discussion and ordinary employment processes.

Most UK universities operate without Oxford- and Cambridge-style EJRA policies. The Academics Against Ageism case is that elite universities can plan succession without an age-based cliff edge.

In addition, most academics in other universities where there is no EJRA choose to retire at an average age of 71 or 72, so having a forced retirement age at 69 increases vacancy creation rates by an insignificant amount, between 2 – 4%.

Myth 5: “Oxford and Cambridge have fixed retirement ages because they are unique.”

Reality: Oxford and Cambridge are top UK and international universities, but they are not exempt from equality principles.

The fact that an institution is prestigious does not make age discrimination proportionate. If a university wants to force people out because of age, it must justify that policy with evidence.

The EHRC guidance is clear: compulsory retirement requires convincing evidence of a legitimate aim and proportionality, and that employers should avoid general assumptions about capability or performance at a particular age.

A key example is the experience of Professor Sir Michael Pepper, a world class leader in his field, who moved to a university in London when his request to extend his job past 67 years old – the previous forced retirement age –  was blocked at the Cambridge School of the Physical Sciences.

Myth 6: “EJRA saves the university money”

Cambridge claims to save approximately £3 million per annum when it sacks approximately 30 senior academics per year. However, these individuals bring in grant income that exceeds this cost. Many of these senior academics are at the top of their game where they attract research grants of £1 million per year.

The stated goals of the EJRA are not to save money by forcing expensive older faculty to retire and to be replaced by cheaper, younger people. If saving money were the main argument for the EJRA, it would be outright illegal.

Furthermore, such assumed cost is, at best, very questionable, as it overlooks the enormous contributions in grant money of some of our more senior colleagues. Data from the UKRI shows that 17% of the sum total of awards went to PIs aged 60 or older.

These are also the largest awards, suggesting that they support the larger and therefore more exciting programmes of work. This means that EJRA in fact leads to a 20% reduction in Cambridge University’s income, putting Cambridge at a competitive disadvantage compared to universities like Imperial or UCL who do not have an EJRA.

Universities exist not just to train postdocs but also to grow world leaders who can bring in big grants and hire postdocs, and EJRA prematurely deprives Cambridge of world leaders.

Myth 7: “EJRA is needed to deal with underperformance.”

Reality: Performance issues should be managed through performance management and appraisals, not by forcibly retiring all staff.

Let us be clear: we believe that if a senior member of staff, or a member of staff from any age group, is not meeting reasonable contributionary expectations, the university should address that through the usual management process, regardless of age.

A blanket age rule removes excellent academics as well as less active ones. It treats age as a proxy for performance — and that is exactly the problem.

Myth 8: “The Penty Report justifies the use of EJRA”

No, the Penty Report (prepared by Professor Penty at University of Cambridge to justify the EJRA policy) contains multiple errors and regrettably a lack of transparency. It persistently conflates retirement-generated vacancies and EJRA-generated vacancies throughout, which are very different.

See here the rebuttal by Linton et al, or the Oxford rebuttal by Ewart. The conclusions of the Penty Report are neither justified nor correct.

In response to our rebuttal of the Penty report’s conclusion (see below), the University in its Grace of 10 June 2024 admits: “The Council accepts that there are difficulties in attempting to conclusively demonstrate the effect of Cambridge’s EJRA on vacancies. In part these arise from a high degree of volatility in the data compounded by the small sample sizes inherent in comparing a single institution with only 22 others.”

The law requires objective evidence and an excuse that it is too difficult to find such evidence is not legally valid. The Ewart tribunal also judged that an EJRA cannot legally be introduced on an “experimental basis” before such evidence is adduced.

This renders the Cambridge University EJRA disproportionate, unjustifiable and open to legal challenges in Employment Tribunals or the High Court.

Myth 9: “Academics can just retire and carry on researching.”

Reality: For many research leaders, formal employment matters.

If your research does not require grants, post-docs or students, you may just retire and carry on with your research, although office or workspace may not be provided. If you need to obtain grants and want to supervise PhD students or work with postdocs, then you cannot just retire and carry on with your research, unless you go through a process of approval, which is currently hard to obtain.

Myth 10: “The rise of AI means universities need to clear space for younger academics.”

Reality: New technologies make intergenerational collaboration more important, not less.

Artificial intelligence is transforming higher education, but it is not an argument for age discrimination.
Universities need the best minds to help students navigate a rapidly changing world. That means drawing on the talents of academics of all ages.

Experienced academics have a vital role to play in helping students understand the opportunities, limitations and ethical implications of AI. They provide institutional memory, disciplinary expertise and critical judgement that technology cannot replace.

The challenges facing younger academics are real. Competition for permanent positions is intense, and universities face significant financial and technological pressures. But forcing older academics to retire will not solve those problems.

The future of higher education depends on collaboration between generations, not replacing one generation with another. Universities should be creating opportunities for younger academics while continuing to value the contribution of experienced scholars who wish to remain active in teaching and research.

Myth 11: "Cambridge voted to keep EJRA and therefore the issue has been settled"

Reality: The Cambridge vote to keep the EJRA policy in 2025 was based upon the data in the Penty Report. This report has been shown by the Linton et al. report to have made a number of key errors.
This vote was therefore not conducted based on the reality of the EJRA policy’s impacts, and therefore should not be treated as final or conclusive. In that vote, over 900 academics voted to abolish forced retirement altogether.